The situation
An employee had received two informal warnings over six months for repeatedly failing to follow reasonable instructions and for poor communication with colleagues. Nothing had improved.
Why it was difficult
The owner had let it drift, hoping it would resolve itself. Acting now, after months of informality, risked looking inconsistent or unfair if it was not handled carefully.
What Samantha did
- Moved the matter into a proper formal process at the right stage
- Set clear, specific expectations and consequences in writing
- Held a fair hearing and issued a formal warning correctly
- Gave the employee a genuine, time-bound opportunity to improve
The outcome
The formal warning landed. Behaviour improved and the situation did not need to escalate to dismissal.
Conduct improved. No further escalation needed.
What this means for you
Informal warnings only work if they lead somewhere. A clear formal step, handled fairly, often resolves what months of drift could not.
Related support
Disciplinary support →Anonymised. Sector, names and identifying details have been removed or changed. Outcomes reflect the specific circumstances of each case and are not a guarantee of any particular result.