Magenta HR Consulting

HR support for small and medium businesses

What HR support does a business your size actually need?

Most owner-managed businesses are either paying for more HR than they use, or carrying risk they have not noticed. Very few have the right thing.

I'm Samantha Newton FCIPD. This page sets out what you need at your size, the three honest ways of getting it, and what each one really costs. If you do not need me, you will be able to tell from this page.

Chartered Fellow CIPD · 25+ years' HR experience · Oxfordshire and UK-wide

The problem is almost never the policy

Small businesses rarely get into trouble because they lacked a document. They get into trouble because a conversation happened without a note, a manager said something that could not be unsaid, or a decision was made quickly on a Friday because the situation had been dragging on for months.

Employment tribunals do not punish you for reaching the wrong conclusion. They punish you for how you got there. You can have an entirely good reason to dismiss someone and still lose, because the process was not followed.

Which means the thing worth buying is not a handbook. It is access to someone who will tell you what to do before you do it.

What changes as you grow

The obligations start at employee number one. What changes with size is how expensive a mistake becomes.

5 to 15 staff

Get the basics right and stop improvising

At this size the owner is HR. The risk is not complexity, it is informality: contracts that were never issued, a handbook nobody has read, and conversations that happened with no record. Most tribunal claims against businesses this size come down to process, not malice.

What you need in place

  • A written statement of the main terms, given on or before the first day of work
  • A disciplinary and grievance procedure that follows the Acas Code
  • Somewhere to get a straight answer before you act, not after

15 to 30 staff

The first real people problems arrive

You now have managers who are not you, which means decisions get made without you seeing them. Performance, absence and conduct issues start appearing and the honest answer is that most owner-managers have never been trained to handle them.

What you need in place

  • Managers who know what they can and cannot say
  • A consistent approach, because inconsistency is what tribunals punish
  • Proper handling of the first grievance, which sets the precedent for every one after it

30 to 60 staff

Exposure outgrows goodwill

At this size a single badly handled dismissal is a five-figure problem, and from 1 January 2027 there is no cap on unfair dismissal compensation at all. You are also likely to be restructuring, acquiring or TUPE-ing something at some point.

What you need in place

  • Someone senior to call before a decision, not after it
  • Independent handling where a complaint names the owner or a director
  • A view on whether it is time to hire in-house, and an honest one

Starting point for the documents: the five HR documents every small business needs →

The three ways businesses get HR support

Set out honestly, including where each one lets you down. I am one of these three, and I am not the right answer for everybody.

Hire someone in-house

Usually from around 50 to 60 staff, or sooner if you are hiring heavily.

Where it works

Someone on site every day who knows every person and every history.

Where it does not

An HR Manager on £50,000 costs nearer £58,000 once National Insurance, pension and holiday are counted. Below about 50 staff there is rarely enough work to justify it, and a single generalist will still be out of their depth on a serious case.

An HR helpline or outsourced package

Common from around 10 staff upward, often sold alongside insurance.

Where it works

Cheap per month, unlimited calls, templates and a handbook.

Where it does not

A different adviser each time, so nobody holds the history of your business. Advice is usually cautious and generic because the adviser carries no risk. Contracts are frequently three or five years with automatic renewal. Read the term before you sign anything.

A specialist you actually know

Works from around 5 staff to 60, which is where most owner-managed businesses sit.

Where it works

The same person every time, who builds real context and will tell you when you are wrong. Serious cases handled properly rather than escalated to someone else.

Where it does not

More per month than a helpline. Not the right answer if what you genuinely need is a cheap handbook and nothing else.

The question that actually matters. Not "what does it cost per month", but "who handles it when something serious happens". A cheap arrangement that escalates your worst case to a stranger is not cheap.

The full comparison, with the real cost of an in-house hire: should you hire an HR person, or bring one in? →

Signs your current arrangement has stopped working

If more than one of these is true, the arrangement is not the one you need.

  • → You are Googling employment law at eleven at night
  • → You have a situation you have been putting off for weeks
  • → A manager has already said something to an employee that you would not have said
  • → Your handbook is three years old and refers to a policy you no longer follow
  • → You asked your helpline a question and got an answer so cautious it was useless
  • → You are paying a solicitor to deal with something that should never have reached a solicitor

What businesses this size say

★★★★★
“Highly recommend Sam. She's HR savvy, pragmatic and commercially driven to help with problems no matter how big or small”
Andie LGoogle review
★★★★★
“We recently moved our zero-hour contract process over to Sam @ Magenta HR, and the experience has been excellent from start to finish. Super professional, efficient, and made the whole process simple and compliant.”
Daryn HeskethGoogle review

Anonymised case studies →

Questions owners ask

At what size does a small business need HR support?

Earlier than most owners expect, but not in the form they expect. From the first employee you have legal obligations: a written statement of the main terms on or before their first day, with the remaining particulars inside two months, a disciplinary and grievance procedure, and the right to be accompanied at formal meetings. What you do not need at five staff is a full-time HR person. You need somewhere to get a straight answer before you act. Hiring in-house rarely makes commercial sense below roughly 50 staff.

How much does HR support cost for a small business in the UK?

It depends entirely on which of three routes you take. An HR Manager on a £50,000 salary costs nearer £58,000 once employer National Insurance, pension and holiday are included. An outsourced helpline is cheap monthly but usually locks you into a three or five year contract. Ongoing Support with Magenta HR is a monthly fee banded by headcount, with a twelve-month minimum term and work beyond the plan at a preferential rate of £120 + VAT per hour against a standard rate of £150 + VAT. Our pricing page sets out the bands.

Is outsourced HR better than hiring someone in-house?

Below about 50 staff, usually yes, on cost alone. But the more important question is who handles the serious case. A single in-house generalist and a helpline adviser can both be out of their depth on a grievance against a director or a dismissal that will be challenged. What matters is whether the person advising you has handled that situation before and will stay with it.

Do I need an employee handbook?

You are legally required to have a disciplinary and grievance procedure and to give employees a written statement of particulars. A handbook is how most businesses deliver those, plus the policies that protect you in practice. An out-of-date handbook is worse than a short accurate one, because it is evidence of a process you did not follow.

What is the difference between HR and Employee Relations?

HR covers everything to do with people: recruitment, contracts, pay, policies, training. Employee Relations is the part that goes wrong: grievances, disciplinaries, investigations, absence, performance, exits and disputes. Most generalist HR support is strongest on the administrative half and weakest on the half that carries the real risk. Magenta HR is an Employee Relations specialism.

Can you help if the situation has already been handled badly?

Yes, and that is how most owners arrive. A meeting happened without notes, or something was said that would have been better left unsaid. That is normal and usually workable. What will not happen is pretending a process was followed when it was not. You will be told where you actually are, what can be put right and what has to be lived with.

General guidance to help you decide your next step, not legal advice. Employment law changes, so always check the current position for your own situation.

Work out what you actually need

A short call, no charge. Tell me the size of the business and what is on your mind. If your current setup is fine, I will tell you that.

Prefer to write? Send me a brief outline. Please do not include employee names or medical details at this stage.