Dismissal decisions
I Think I Need to Dismiss an Employee
You have reached the point where you do not see how this can continue. The situation is not improving. You are starting to think about ending the employment. But you are not sure how to do it properly, or whether the moment has actually come.
You are probably not wrong. The question is how.
Most business owners who reach this point have tried. They have had conversations, given chances, hoped things would improve. Getting to the point of considering dismissal is not a failure. It is often a sign that you have been patient longer than was strictly necessary.
The challenge is that dismissal is a legally high-stakes step. Getting it right requires the right reason, the right process, the right documentation, and the right timing. Missing any of those means a decision that was commercially correct can become legally costly.
The most common mistake is not the decision itself. It is acting on it before the process is in place, or skipping steps because the situation feels clear-cut to you. Tribunals do not assess whether your decision felt obvious. They assess whether your process was fair.
What happens when dismissal is handled incorrectly
- Unfair dismissal claims with compensation awards up to £115,115 (2024/25), plus basic award on top
- Discrimination claims, which are uncapped, if protected characteristics are anywhere in the picture
- Legal fees, management time and the disruption of a tribunal process lasting 12 to 18 months
- Reputational damage in a sector or local market where word travels
- A finding that sets a precedent for how you manage people in future
- The cost of re-hiring and training a replacement while the claim is still live
How to approach this properly
- 1
Be clear about the reason for dismissal
Different reasons require different processes. Misconduct, capability, redundancy and some other substantial reason all have distinct legal requirements. Being clear about the actual reason, not just the feeling, shapes everything that follows.
- 2
Assess what has already happened
Has a formal process begun? Have warnings been issued? Has performance been managed? Or are you at the start? The answer determines whether you are in a position to proceed or whether more steps are needed before dismissal is defensible.
- 3
Consider whether settlement is a cleaner option
In some situations, a protected conversation and settlement agreement is faster, lower risk and less disruptive than a full formal process. This is worth understanding before committing to a route that could take months.
- 4
Get proper advice before you say or do anything formal
The point at which most dismissals go wrong is before any formal letter is sent, in a conversation that was not protected, an email that was not carefully worded, or an action taken without the right groundwork. A single session gives you a complete picture of your options, your risks, and what to do in the right order.
Common questions
Questions business owners ask about this
Can I dismiss an employee without going through a formal process?+
No, not fairly. Even where the reason for dismissal is entirely genuine, misconduct, poor performance, redundancy, you are required to follow a fair process. Dismissing without the correct steps, regardless of the reason, gives the employee strong grounds for an unfair dismissal claim. The process matters as much as the reason.
How long does it take to dismiss an employee properly?+
It depends on the type of dismissal. A disciplinary process for misconduct can be completed in a few weeks if the investigation is straightforward. A performance-related dismissal typically takes longer because of the improvement plan period. Redundancy requires a minimum consultation period. Rushing any of these carries significant risk.
What is the difference between dismissal for misconduct and dismissal for capability?+
Misconduct is about behaviour, what the employee has done or failed to do. Capability is about their ability to do the job, including performance and health. Each requires a different process, different documentation, and a different approach. Conflating the two is a common mistake that creates legal risk.
What if the employee has less than two years of service?+
Employees with less than two years' service cannot generally bring an unfair dismissal claim, but they can still bring discrimination claims if those grounds exist. You still need to handle the dismissal carefully. And if the reason or approach could be seen as discriminatory, the two-year rule provides no protection at all.
Could a settlement agreement be a better option than dismissal?+
Sometimes, yes. A settlement agreement brings the employment to an end by mutual agreement, with the employee waiving their right to claim. It is often faster, cleaner, and lower risk than a formal process, particularly where the formal process would be long, contested, or emotionally difficult. It is worth understanding both options before committing to either.
What does it actually cost if a dismissal goes wrong?+
The compensatory award for unfair dismissal can reach £115,115 (2024/25). Add a basic award calculated from age and length of service, your legal fees, management time, and the disruption to the business. Discrimination claims are uncapped. Most business owners are surprised by how quickly the total exposure adds up, and how avoidable it usually was.
You might also be dealing with
These situations often come up alongside each other.
Ready when you are
Not sure what to do next?
If this sounds like what you're dealing with, the fastest way to get clarity is the Employee Situation Check.
You deal directly with Samantha. FCIPD Chartered Fellow. 25 years handling situations like this. Reply within one working day.