Preparing for a difficult conversation
I Need to Have a Difficult Conversation
You know what needs to be said. You have probably rehearsed it. But you are not sure how to open it, how to stay on track if it goes sideways, or how to make sure it actually changes something. This is about helping you have the conversation properly.
The conversation itself is rarely the problem
Most difficult conversations in a work context are not as hard as the anticipation of them. What makes them feel hard is the uncertainty: how will the person react, what if they say something unexpected, what if it makes things worse?
The answer to most of that uncertainty is preparation. Business owners who know what they are going to say, why they are saying it, what they need the other person to hear, and what the conversation is intended to achieve find that the conversation is far more manageable than the version they rehearsed in their head.
The other thing that helps is understanding what the conversation actually is. An informal check-in about something you have noticed is very different from a formal performance meeting. Knowing which one you are having, and what the rules are for each, changes how you frame it and what you can say.
What happens when the conversation keeps getting delayed
- The issue grows and becomes significantly harder to address fairly
- The employee continues the behaviour without understanding its impact
- Other team members see that nothing is being done and draw their own conclusions
- If a formal process eventually becomes necessary, the lack of prior conversation weakens your position
- The emotional weight of the unresolved situation affects your own management capacity
- A situation that could have been resolved with one clear conversation requires a formal process instead
How to prepare and have the conversation well
- 1
Get clear on what you are actually trying to achieve
Before the conversation, answer this: what do you need the employee to understand, agree to, or change? Not just 'I need to say something about X', but specifically what outcome you are working towards. That clarity shapes everything, how you open it, how you respond if they push back, and how you know whether it went well.
- 2
Prepare your key points, not a script
Know the specific facts you are raising. What you observed, when, and what the impact was. You are not reciting a list, you are having a conversation. But having the key points clear in your mind means you stay on track if the employee tries to redirect or challenge the premise.
- 3
Choose the right time, place and setting
Private. Unrushed. Not at the end of a difficult day, not on a Friday afternoon, not immediately before a busy period. Give yourself time to have the conversation properly. A rushed difficult conversation is almost always worse than a delayed one.
- 4
Let them respond, and genuinely listen
The conversation has to go both ways. Give the employee the space to give their perspective. Sometimes it changes the picture. Sometimes it does not. Either way, a conversation where the employee felt heard is much harder to challenge later than one where they felt lectured at.
- 5
Follow up in writing afterwards
A brief summary of what was discussed, any agreements reached, and what happens next. This protects both parties, removes ambiguity, and creates a record if anything formal is needed later. It does not need to be lengthy, a short email is usually enough.
Common questions
Questions business owners ask about this
How do I start a difficult conversation with an employee?+
Start by being clear about the purpose of the conversation before you have it. Know what you need to say, why it matters, and what you want the outcome to be. In the conversation itself, open with the subject directly but calmly, not defensively and not with excessive preamble. Something like: 'I wanted to talk to you about something I've noticed and I'd like your perspective on it.' Clarity from the start is kinder and more effective than a gradual build-up.
What if the employee denies everything or becomes defensive?+
This is normal. Some defensiveness is natural when someone feels criticised or under scrutiny. Your role is to stay factual and calm. You are not there to persuade them to agree with your view. You are there to raise a concern, hear their perspective, and make clear what needs to change. If they deny everything, note that you heard their view and confirm in writing what was discussed.
Should I give the employee notice that a difficult conversation is coming?+
For informal conversations, some advance notice is courteous but not always necessary. For formal processes, disciplinaries, performance reviews, grievance hearings, the employee must be given adequate written notice of the meeting and its purpose. The right amount of notice depends on the formality of the process and what is being discussed.
What do I do after a difficult conversation?+
Follow up in writing. A brief email confirming what was discussed, any agreements reached, and what happens next creates a record that protects both parties and removes ambiguity. It does not need to be formal or lengthy. Something brief and factual is usually enough. Not doing this is one of the most common management mistakes.
What if the difficult conversation is about something personal, like hygiene, mental health or relationships at work?+
These conversations require more care, but they are still necessary. The approach needs to be genuinely respectful, focused on impact rather than judgement, and private. Some personal topics, particularly those connected to mental health or disability, have legal dimensions that are worth understanding before the conversation happens. Getting advice on how to frame it is sensible.
Is a difficult conversation the same as starting a formal process?+
Not necessarily. Many difficult conversations are informal and should be. They are a way of addressing something early, before it requires formal action. The line between informal and formal matters legally. If a conversation is the first step in a disciplinary or performance process, that changes the formality required. Knowing which register you are in before you start is important.
You might also be dealing with
These situations often come up alongside each other.
Ready when you are
Not sure what to do next?
If this sounds like what you're dealing with, the fastest way to get clarity is the Employee Situation Check.
You deal directly with Samantha. FCIPD Chartered Fellow. 25 years handling situations like this. Reply within one working day.